Advertisement
Advertisement
Workers clean hair for export in Yangon, Myanmar, in June 2018. Photo: Reuters
Opinion
Outside In
by David Dodwell
Outside In
by David Dodwell

What Donald Trump should know about the global trade in human hair

  • The story of the hair trade is one of women in developing countries cutting, collecting and untangling hair to make a living. But it is also a story about billions of dollars in global trade

 

Recent heart-rending BBC reports of young – and not so young – Venezuelan women selling their hair to keep starvation at bay as they trekked overland towards Colombia and the United States border reminded me of one of the world’s least understood export industries, the global trade in human hair. 

A week in meetings in Atlanta last week also brought me face to face with the other end of the business, where thousands of young black women have turned hair braiding into an awesome art.
As Emma Tarlo, anthropology professor at Goldsmiths, University of London, drily notes in her monumental Entanglement: The Secret Lives of Hair, “natural hair is not as simple as it first appears, for since time immemorial people have been arranging their hair in more or less spectacular ways which have often involved the addition of extra fibre, whether animal, vegetable, mineral or human”.

At the outset, she complains that the global human hair trade is “a backstage business about which little is known to those outside the trade”. And after several years of combing the world to research her tome, the numbers she garners still seem very shaky.

The trade in human hair – yes, there really is a customs classification for wigs, beards and brows – may amount to around US$2.5 billion, and beyond this, the hair extension industry in hairdressing salons from London to Harlem to Lagos probably adds several billion more.

But getting more accurate numbers seems a forlorn task, unaided by any official trade data.

As someone who nowadays has almost no hair to boast about, the world of hair is about as mysterious as tree-sloth toenail clippings, but in many parts of the world it is a huge business, and has been for centuries.

It is strange but true that so many cultures attribute great mystical significance to hair and go to great lengths to prevent strangers from getting their hands on a strand and using it to inflict magical harm, and yet those same cultures have become huge traders in the stuff.

It seems the world’s largest sources of human hair are India, Bangladesh, Myanmar and China. And by far the dominant buyers are in the US (with a surprising demand from Nigeria and Ghana).

And yet, anyone spending US$2,000 to US$3,000 on a fine human-hair wig today would probably claim the hair comes from Brazil. If a trader wants a good price, he is unlikely to admit its true origins.

Even for scientists, determining the origin of hair seems a challenging business. Top-quality hair, called “remy” (which should be 30 inches or longer and should never have been chemically treated) can cost US$400 a kilo, and will almost always be black. Getting it to look silky blond takes weeks of chemical treatment.

For many years, hair from China was blacklisted as “communist hair”, and so entered the world’s markets as anything but Chinese.

There are constant stories of hair coming from corpses, prisoners, workhouses or hospitals.

Victoria Beckham back in 2003 joked that her extensions probably came from Russian prisoners: “so I've got Russian cell block H on my head”. The Moscow Centre for Prison Reform admitted at the time that it was possible.

A huge amount of “ethical hair” comes from Hindu temples like those in Andhra Pradesh, where women shave their heads for religious reasons and earn millions for the temple authorities.

Tarlo’s research finds Myanmar to be a huge source of remy hair, with the township of Pyawbwe, close to Yangon, boasting around 10,000 companies in the human hair trade, some of them employing more than 4,000 people. She estimates at least half a million Burmese women working in the business.

Victoria Beckham has joked that her hair extensions probably came from Russian prisoners. Photo: Reuters
Ghoulishly, much of this business has little to do with freshly cropped tresses, but is built around “combings” or hair waste. The average human head at any one time has between 50,000 and 100,000 hairs, and we on average shed 50 to 100 hairs per day.

In poor districts of many developing countries, women gather and save these hairs daily from hairbrushes, waiting for the regular visit of the itinerant trader who buys their hair. It earns them welcome pocket money, and underpins a large part of the world’s human hair business.

India’s biggest human hair exporter sells about 10 tonnes of such “hair balls” every month. Go online, and you can find “waste human hair balls” for sale.

Tens of thousands of poor rural Burmese women spend millions of hours untangling these hair balls for traders in and around Pyawbwe. It takes about 50 hours to untangle a kilo of hair balls.

No wonder Tarlo writes: “Sitting on the ground untangling balls of comb waste must rank as one of the most monotonous, unhealthy, poorly paid jobs in the world, requiring levels of patience and endurance that only people who lack alternatives would tolerate.”

But for those living in poverty, it offers a fragile lifeline of sorts.

As communities are lifted out of poverty, it is perhaps unsurprising that their willingness to part with their tresses – or to unpick hair balls – has declined over the years, leading to a chronic surplus of demand over supply.

This inevitably led to the surge in demand for synthetic hair (which today accounts for perhaps 90 per cent of the global market in wigs and other hair products), and the boom in wigs as mass fashion.

A worker in Qingdao, Shandong province, makes wigs for soccer fans in the lead-up to the 2018 World Cup. Synthetic hair has become a big business because of a chronic surplus of demand over supply. Photo: Reuters

For this reason, for a short while in the 1970s, Hong Kong was thrust into the heart of the business. From eight wig factories in 1963, business boomed to a point in 1970 when Hong Kong boasted 400 factories employing 40,000 people.

Like most Hong Kong manufacturing, it moved to the mainland in the 1980s, and today, Xuchang in Henan is the world’s “wig city”.

An estimated 88 per cent of the world’s real hair wigs and extensions are today exported from China, earning about US$1.6 billion in 2016.

I suspect that was not on US President Donald Trump’s tariff radar screen in the trade war, but given the president’s interest in hair art, perhaps it should have been.

David Dodwell researches and writes about global, regional and Hong Kong challenges from a Hong Kong point of view

Post